College Media Network

The Observer

The Student Newspaper of Case Western Reserve University
  • Home
  • News
    • Sports
      • Opinion
        • Focus
          • About Us
            • Info
            • Staff
          • Archives
          • Options
            • Login
            • Register
            • Write to the Editor
            • Syndication
            • Search
          • New Features
            • Plan Spring Break!
            • Learn about your Finances
          • Advertising

          State of health care not worthy of "crisis" label

          Tiffany Oliver

          Issue date: 3/26/10 Section: Opinion
          • Print
          • Email
          • 2 of 2
          Many people who support health care reform argue that health care is a right. I agree that health care is a right protected under the Fourteenth Amendment's due process clause, but I do not think health insurance is a right. Currently, hospitals do not deny care to those who either choose not to have insurance or cannot afford it.

          Rates should be higher for those who use hospitals and health services more, because they cost insurance companies more than those who limit their interaction with doctors to yearly physicals. One issue with not allowing companies to charge higher rates for sickly customers is an across the board increase for health insurance for all customers. Common sense holds that if health insurance companies must retain pricy customers, or that they cannot deny coverage based on preexisting health conditions, companies will increase everybody's rates in order to recover lost profits. Everybody will pay for reforms that perhaps half of all Americans want. Not to mention, requiring all Americans to have insurance by 2014 will cause a shortage of doctors and nurses available to treat patients.

          I feel bad for those who cannot afford health care, but I believe the correct response to the problem is the solution that results in the least amount of government intervention, and in my opinion that is offering tax cuts for those who cannot afford insurance. Instead of costly government regulation, Congress could provide tax cuts to lower/middle-class Americans who are most likely to be uninsured, equivalent to the amount of money needed to pay for insurance. I can accept such a solution, because it limits the role that government plays in my life, and I admit that after the Bush administration, I am hesitant to grant extensive power to Congress or the President, especially to those who proudly claim to be progressives.
          2 of 2

          Article Tools

          Be the first to comment on this story

          In This Issue


          • Can you name this place?
          • Cleveland Institute of Art announces new president
          • Have you heard about The Confused Greenies
          • Relay For Life hoping for success as event begins today
          • Undergraduate Student Government inaugurations bring new faces, new initiatives


          • For Gobies, this weekend is first step to goal
          • Howe's love of game grows
          • Smetona's workouts work out
          • Spartan Spotlight: Jon Edmunds
          • Spartans drop 13th and 14th straight to Wooster
          • Spartans go 2-2 against Wolverines, Lords
          • Spartans near best win total in school history
          • Whalen auditions for Browns, Mangini
          • When fans care


          • City boasts unusual outdoor spaces for observing Cleveland in springtime
          • Editorial: Although meal plan policy remains unchanged, policy seems fundamentally flawed
          • Letters to the editor: Greek Life opportunities
          • Political leaders are ill-equipped to decide when wars are "just"
          • Sticks and stones: bullying still hurts, but can be stopped with just one word
          • What's your favorite flower?


          • August: Osage County astonishes audiences
          • International Conference on Narrative successful and engaging
          • Just a Perfect Day
          • Pokémon returns to Nintendo DS with best games in years
          • Rompers: this season's divisive trend
          • Safety First
          • Take a picture, It'll Last Longer: CIA student photo exhibition
          • The Buzz
          • Tremont: The A-list of Cleveland's bars
          National College Advertising and Marketing | Privacy Policy (9/9/09) | Terms of Use (9/9/09)
          Content Submission Agreement (8/23/07) | Copyright Compliance Policy (4/27/09) | RSS Terms of Use



          This Week's Front Page

          Download Print Edition PDF