College Media Network

The Observer

The Student Newspaper of Case Western Reserve University
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
    • Fun Page
    • Opinion
    • Focus
      • About Us
      • Options
        • Login
        • Register
        • Letter to the Editor
        • Advertise
        • Syndication
        • Podcasts
        • Classifieds
        • Archives
        • Search
      • Blog

      Test bank not issue of Greeks versus non-Greeks

      Issue date: 4/10/09 Section: Opinion
      • Print
      • Email
      • Page 1 of 1
      To the Editor:

      Frustration with The Observer and their perpetual inaccurate reporting compels me to write. Gillian Seaman's article "University-wide test bank still in development" and the editorial in last week's Observer are both laced with inaccurate assertions and misrepresentations of myself and the Academic Integrity Board.

      With selective reporting for the past two years, The Observer created the "Greek vs. non-Greek" fiction, and after the April 3 publication, I cannot continue to allow The Observer to badger the Greeks in the Academic Integrity Board's or my name.

      The misstatements began when Misia Yuhasz contacted the Academic Integrity Board on Oct. 15, 2007 about the AI Board's student survey. ("Academic Integrity Board seeks student input on ethical issues," Nov. 2, 2007.) Yuhasz specifically asked about complaints regarding Greek test banks.

      My answer to this single question has continuously shaped this issue to the exclusion of all my other remarks. Yuhasz and The Observer used my answer out of context, misreported the Academic Integrity Board's feelings, as well as the poll's intent, and fabricated an anti-Greek article.

      Seaman's recent article continues this inaccuracy by writing, "One of the main reasons given for the development of the test bank was the supposed advantage Greek organizations had over non-Greeks due to their access to individual test banks."

      This has never been the "main purpose" of the test bank nor has the Academic Integrity Board ever presented it as so. The board aimed to eliminate advantages by any person holding past materials. The Greeks are only one of many sources from which students obtain past materials, such as through friends, family members, and other organizations. However, The Observer continually focuses only on the Greeks, conjuring up a false division between the Greeks and non-Greeks.

      Also, I do not appreciate the insinuation that the Academic Integrity Board or myself is somehow hiding information from Case students. The facts about the test bank would have been readily available to you had you approached those involved in its creation in an appropriate manner.

      I appreciate The Observer and their role; however, by inaccurately portraying me and the Academic Integrity Board and perpetuating their own version of the truth, The Observer is doing our school a gross disservice, one which I hope this letter will rectify.

      Stephanie Ash

      Chair, Academic Integrity Board (2007-2008)
      Page 1 of 1

      Article Tools

      Be the first to comment on this story

      In This Issue


      • From newspapers to the net: famed editor delivers lecture on future of journalism
      • G20 protest in London: A firsthand account
      • ITS prepares for mail switch
      • New USG president to be chosen tonight: Douglas or Pinder
      • Sigma Phi Epsilon, Phi Mu win Greek Week competition
      • Understanding car insurance
      • Village at 115 awarded LEED Silver rating


      • Baseball: Spartans bring brooms vs. Bethany, Grove City
      • Softball gets out of jams, into wins
      • Spartan Spotlight: Clay Hurley
      • Tennis: Women snap losing streak
      • Track & Field: Women's track takes fifth, men take ninth at DePauw
      • Ultimate: Women Gobies have fighting chance at regionals
      • Water polo workhorses

      Fun Page

      • Crossword Answers
      • Jumble Answers
      • Sudoku Answers


      • Community Supported Agriculture benefits both consumers, farmers
      • Don't let weather dictate your mood
      • Editorial: Administration should take responsibility for CSP
      • Students find motivation to serve in local, international efforts
      • Test bank not issue of Greeks versus non-Greeks
      • Coverage of AIB was slanted
      • Progress on test bank available


      • Andrew Bird charms crowd with musicianship, melody and humor
      • CIM Orchestra to hold inspirational concert at Severance
      • Eldred delivers a solid ensemble performance with their latest, Stage Door
      • New movie review site combines Facebook with Rotten Tomatoes
      • Secret Ingredient: Pineapple
      • Sex and Dating: Serial Monogamy
      • Spartans of Style: Back to the '80s
      • The Buzz
      National College Advertising and Marketing | Privacy Policy (8/15/07) | Terms of Use (4/28/08)
      Content Submission Agreement (8/23/07) | Copyright Compliance Policy (8/25/07) | RSS Terms of Use